You Got a Ticket - Are You Under Arrest?

The "I Got a Ticket" Confusion

I receive this call at least once a week: a worried driver explaining they received a citation and have to appear in court. They want to know if they've been arrested, if this will go on their record, and whether they need an attorney. The answer depends entirely on what type of citation they received - and most people have no idea there's a difference.

Florida law creates three fundamentally different categories of citations, each with dramatically different consequences. A civil traffic infraction and a Notice to Appear may look nearly identical on paper - both are printed on similar forms, both require a signature, and both specify a court date. But one is a civil matter comparable to a parking ticket, while the other is a criminal arrest that can follow you for life.

As a former law enforcement officer, I've issued both types of citations. Officers are trained on the legal distinctions, but they're not required to explain them to you at the scene. Many drivers sign their citation, drive away, and have no idea they've just been criminally arrested. They assume they'll handle it like any other ticket - pay a fine or show up to court, then move on with their lives. By the time they realize the stakes, they've often made critical mistakes that compromise their defense.

Understanding what you're actually facing isn't just academic. It determines whether you need an attorney, whether you have constitutional rights at stake, and whether a conviction will appear on background checks for the rest of your career.

Civil Traffic Infractions: Serious but Not Criminal

The vast majority of traffic tickets in Florida are civil infractions governed by Florida Statutes Chapters 316, 318, 320, and 322. Speeding, running red lights, improper lane changes, following too closely - these are civil matters, not criminal charges. The distinction matters because civil infractions carry fundamentally different consequences and procedures than criminal cases.

A civil traffic infraction cannot result in jail time. You have no right to a jury trial because there's nothing criminal at stake. The state will not appoint you a public defender because you're not facing criminal penalties. Most importantly, a civil infraction cannot create a criminal record - it will never appear on a criminal background check, regardless of the outcome.

The penalties for civil infractions are limited to fines, points on your license, traffic school requirements, and in some cases administrative license suspension. These consequences are serious - accumulated points can raise your insurance rates, and enough violations can result in a suspended license. But they're civil penalties, not criminal punishment. When you resolve a civil traffic infraction, you walk away with no arrest record and no criminal history.

The "Mandatory Court Appearance" Trap

Here's where most people get confused. Certain civil infractions require a mandatory court appearance - you cannot simply pay the fine online and move on. When drivers see "mandatory court appearance" on their citation, many assume they're facing criminal charges. This assumption is incorrect, and it causes unnecessary panic.

Speeding 30 miles per hour or more over the posted limit requires a mandatory court appearance in Florida. So do school zone violations, construction zone violations, and certain crash-related citations. But these remain civil infractions. The mandatory appearance exists because the Legislature determined these violations are serious enough to warrant judicial review - not because they're criminal offenses.

Should you take a mandatory court appearance seriously? Absolutely. Consider hiring an attorney to negotiate point reductions or argue for dismissal. But don't assume you're facing criminal charges simply because you have to appear in court. The mandatory appearance requirement changes the procedure, not the fundamental nature of the violation.

The Notice to Appear: A Criminal Arrest in Disguise

This is where people get burned. A Notice to Appear looks like a traffic ticket. It's often issued on the same form, requires a signature in the same place, and specifies a court date just like a civil infraction. The officer may hand it to you and say "here's your ticket" without any further explanation. You sign it, the officer leaves, and you drive away assuming you'll handle it like any other citation.

But a Notice to Appear is not a traffic ticket. It is a criminal arrest. Legally, you have been arrested, charged with a criminal offense, and released on your own recognizance pending your court date. The NTA is simply a release mechanism that substitutes for taking you to jail, booking you, and making you post bond. The signature you provided isn't just acknowledging the citation - it's your promise to appear in criminal court.

Officers commonly issue NTAs for first-time misdemeanors: petit theft, trespassing, disorderly conduct, possession of drug paraphernalia, minor in possession of alcohol, and similar offenses. The NTA process exists because it's more efficient than physical arrest for low-level crimes - it reduces jail overcrowding and saves processing time. But efficiency for law enforcement doesn't change the nature of the charge. These are criminal cases with criminal consequences.

Understanding the Three Types of Florida Citations

The following table summarizes the critical distinctions between the three types of citations you may receive in Florida. Understanding which category your citation falls into determines your legal rights, potential consequences, and appropriate response.

Why This Distinction Matters: Real-World Consequences

The difference between a civil infraction and a Notice to Appear isn't just legal terminology - it has concrete implications for employment, licensing, and your future. Many job applications ask directly: "Have you ever been arrested?" If you received a civil traffic infraction, even one requiring mandatory court appearance, the answer is no. If you received a Notice to Appear, the answer is yes - because you were arrested, even though you weren't taken to jail.

Professional licensing boards for attorneys, medical professionals, nurses, financial advisors, and many other regulated professions require disclosure of arrests and criminal history. A misdemeanor conviction for a crime of dishonesty - such as petit theft - can disqualify you from licensure or result in disciplinary action against an existing license. Even if you believe your case is minor, the professional consequences can be career-ending.

Failure to Appear: Civil vs. Criminal Consequences

The consequences of missing your court date depend entirely on what type of citation you received. For a civil traffic infraction, failing to appear typically results in a default judgment against you - you're found responsible for the violation, assessed fines and points, and your license may be suspended until you resolve the matter. Serious, but not criminal.

For a Notice to Appear, failing to appear is a separate criminal offense. The court will issue a warrant for your arrest, and you'll face additional charges on top of the original offense. You can be arrested at any future traffic stop, at the airport, or whenever you encounter law enforcement. What started as a misdemeanor shoplifting case becomes multiple criminal charges with compounding consequences.

What To Do When You Receive a Citation

Your first step should be determining exactly what type of citation you received. Look at the citation carefully. Is it marked as a civil traffic infraction, or does it reference criminal statutes? Does it mention a specific criminal offense like petit theft, trespassing, or disorderly conduct? If you're unsure, consult with an attorney before making any decisions about how to proceed.

The most important thing is to understand what you're facing before you decide how to respond. A civil infraction and a criminal arrest require fundamentally different approaches. Treating a criminal case like a traffic ticket - or treating a traffic ticket like a criminal emergency - leads to poor outcomes either way.

Related Articles

Related Resources

• Speeding Ticket Defense
• Moving Violations
• Criminal Traffic Offenses
• Theft Defense